Already on ArticleSlash?

Forgot your password? Sign Up

Plasma or LCD: Which is right for you?


Visitors: 356

Is there a difference in picture quality between plasma and LCD screens and normal CRT TVs? It's not what's happening behind the screen that's important — it's how the screen performs as a television that matters the most. In that regard, both plasma and LCD sets produce excellent pictures, although some home entertainment specialists and gamers still say CRTs produce the best overall images (although the latest plasmas are particularly good, and LCD sets are quickly catching up in terms of quality with advances like LED backlighting). Those same home entertainment specialists will tell you that for basic home theatre-like usage, plasma screens have a slight edge over LCDs. This is because plasma screens can display blacks more accurately than LCDs can, which means better contrast and detail in dark scenes.

The nature of LCD technology, where a backlight shines through the LCD layer, means it's hard for it to achieve true blacks because there's always some light leakage from between pixels. This is steadily improving with every new generation of LCD, though. What advantages does plasma have over LCD? Apart from better contrast due to its ability to show deeper blacks, plasma screens typically have better viewing angles than LCD.

Viewing angles are how far you can sit on either side of a screen before the picture's quality is affected. You tend to see some brightness and colour shift when you're on too far of an angle with LCDs, while a plasma's picture remains fairly solid. This is steadily changing, with more and more LCDs entering the market with viewing angles equal to some plasmas. Plasmas can also produce a brighter colour, once again due to light leakage on an LCD affecting its colour saturation. Plasma pundits will also tell you that some LCD screens have a tendency to blur images, particularly during fast-moving scenes in movies or in sports. While that was true for older generation LCD screens, newer models have improved significantly — so much so that the differences in performance between LCDs and plasmas in this regard is almost negligible.

(While the pixel response time, measured in milliseconds (ms), can give you some indication of an LCD's performance with fast-moving scenes, it's not always reliable. ) Traditionally, the biggest advantage plasmas have had over their LCD cousins is price, particularly in the large screen end of the market. Depending on the resolution, plasma is still able to beat most equivalently-priced LCD screens. Plasmas being sold in Australia generally run between 42 and 63 inches wide, with the cheapest 1024x768 standard-definition 42-inch selling for approximately AU$1700.

However, you can also find some 32-inch plasmas on the market, and they can be found for under AU$1000, but we think LCDs offer a better deal at this size. Sets that are 60 inches are becoming more mainstream, and are still cheaper than LCDs of the same size, eg, the run-out Pioneer PDP-LX609A goes for about AU$12,500. LCDs, on the other hand, generally top out around the 52-inch mark — though there have been some ludicrously expensive 70-inch Sony LCDs available.

Price parity is starting to occur with plasmas and LCD with sizes over 50 inches. What advantages does LCD have over plasma? Apart from becoming increasingly price competitive, LCD has the edge over plasma in several other key areas. LCDs tend to have higher native resolution than plasmas of similar size, which means more pixels on a screen.

LCDs also tend to consume less power than plasma screens, with some of the newer Eco" LCD panels able to use half of the power than equivalent plasmas, with the trade-off being lower brightness. In terms of bulk, LCDs are also generally lighter than similar-sized plasmas, making it easier to move around or wall mount. This is because LCDs use plastic in their screen make-up whereas plasmas tend to use glass. LCD pundits point to the belief that LCDs have a longer lifespan than plasma screens. This may have been true of earlier plasma models, which would lose half of their brightness after more than 20,000 hours of viewing. However, many plasmas available on the market today quote a lifespan of about 60,000 hours, which is the same as LCD. This means they will last for almost seven years if left on 24 hours a day. Last year, LCD finally caught up to the quality of plasma with the introduction of LED backlighting. Instead of lighting the screen with fluorescent tubes, as is traditional, it uses banks of LED lights. There are two types of LED lighting: direct and edge. Direct backlighting is arguably better because manufacturers are able to turn sections of the screen lighting off — meaning higher contrast. Edge-lighting is as it sounds, using a series of LEDs along the edge of the screen. The light is then spread evenly across the screen using a series of mirrors. Most thin LCDs arriving on the market use this method. Look out for more LED-backlit screens this year, but be aware they are NOT a new category of screen, and not to be confused with OLED. You might have also heard that plasmas suffer from screen burn-in, an affliction not commonly associated with LCDs. Screen burn in occurs when an image is left too long on a screen, resulting in a ghost of that image burned in". Newer plasmas are less susceptible to this thanks to improved technology and features such as screensavers, but burn-in can still be a problem. However, after a few days most burnt-in images will fade — they are no longer permanent

LCD stand

, ,

Article Source:

Rate this Article: 
What Are the Various Features of LCD and Plasma TV?
Rated 4 / 5
based on 5 votes

Related Articles:

LCD Vs Plasma TVs Which is Better?

by: Howard Smith (July 15, 2008) 
(Shopping and Product Reviews/Electronics)

LCD, DLP Or Plasma? Oh My!

by: Frank Sarntarpia (May 27, 2008) 
(Home Improvement/Audio Video)

Plasma TV vs LCD TVs - Which Is Better

by: Alan Kenyon (August 31, 2007) 
(Home Improvement/Audio Video)

LCD and Plasma TVs: The Best of the Best

by: Eric Stauffer (July 12, 2010) 
(Shopping and Product Reviews/Electronics)

Using LCD and plasma TV outside

by: Graham Gallagher (January 22, 2012) 
(Computers and Technology/Hardware)

Plasma TV Or LCD TV

by: Stanley Morse (July 26, 2008) 
(Shopping and Product Reviews/Electronics)

How to Get the Best LCD Or Plasma TV

by: Jonathan C. Mulder (December 13, 2008) 
(Shopping and Product Reviews/Electronics)

How Are Plasma TV and LCD TV Different From Each Other?

by: Jonathan C. Mulder (December 14, 2008) 
(Shopping and Product Reviews/Electronics)

How to buy a plasma TV?

by: Raj Agrwl (February 04, 2010) 
(Shopping and Product Reviews/Electronics)

What Are the Various Features of LCD and Plasma TV?

by: Jonathan C. Mulder (December 13, 2008) 
(Shopping and Product Reviews/Electronics)