300 Million People, 300 ETFs


Visitors: 196

As the American population crossed the 300 million mark, the number of ETFs on the market passed 300. No doubt many investors are a bit confused as to how they differ and which ones they should pick for their portfolios.

When the rubber hits the road, there are two ETF issues that are paramount: what companies are in the ETF basket and how are they weighted in the basket. A less than perfect analogy would be a trip to the grocery store. With a mutual fund, immediately upon entering you hand over your grocery cart to a fund manager and they wander through the store picking items for you. With an ETF, you hand it over to a robot that goes down the aisles selecting items based on some process such as shelf space, nutrition or food group. Value investors might only buy items on sale.

About 90% of the ETFs out there weight the companies in the basket based on their market capitalization or market value. This is the number of shares outstanding times the current share price. Market value weighting of companies in indexes is the conventional norm and widely accepted by the institutional establishment.

The largest family of ETFs on the market is iShares and all their ETFs are market cap weighted. There is almost no chance that they will deviate from this philosophy. Recognizing the tremendous lead that iShares ETFs has built, their competitors have little choice but to innovate with other strategies to capture market share.

For example, Rydex launched in 2003 the S&P equal weight ETF (RSP) which weighs each of the companies in the S&P 500 index equally at 2% each rather than the top heavy market cap weighted index. When the big stocks soar such as in the late 1990s, RSP will lag but in the difficult 200-2005 period, the annualized return for the equal weight ETF was 8.06% versus 1.13% for the traditional index. This week Rydex is introducing nine new U. S. sector equal weighted ETFs which represent the different sectors that make up the S&P 500 index.

The Powershares ETFs take another approach. They create an index and weight companies in the ETF basket based on a model which they describe but do not disclose. Normally, they have a maximum weighting policy which prevents large companies from dominating the basket. The weightings of companies in the Powershares ETF baskets fall between the extremes of the market value and equal weight. One issue is that investors won’t know for some time whether the models will yield superior returns.

Another fairly new approach is that offered by the Wisdom Tree family of ETFs. Wisdom Tree weights companies in their ETF baskets by their record of increasing cash dividends. This gives investors another pattern of distribution and falls between the extremes. Backtesting shows a performance advantage over market cap weighting but time will tell. Wisdom Tree recently introduced 11 international sector ETFs and offers unique ETFs in areas such as international small cap and mid cap ETFs.

Don’t become overwhelmed by the choices out there. The Chartwell ETF Advisor uses a blend of these different ETFs in building its model ETF portfolios for members. Each family of ETFs offers a philosophy that will work best in different markets. We sold the S&P 500 equal weight ETF some time ago and moved into a market cap weighted one to take advantage of the rotation to mega cap. You might consider Chartwell or another advisor to help you make the right choices. Think of your ETF portfolio as a cooking recipe, the ingredients need to blend well together and do not stand alone.

Don’t forget to “look under the hood” of an ETF before buying it. You certainly don’t buy things in the grocery store without even looking at them.

Carl T. Delfeld President & Publisher Chartwell Partners http://www.chartwelladvisor.com

Carl has over twenty years of experience in the global investment business with a strong background in Asia.

  • Author of global investor primer “The New Global Investor"

  • President of the global investment advisory firm Chartwell Partners

  • Publisher of the Chartwell Advisor ETF Report and Asia-Pacific Growth

  • Columnist on global investing with Forbes Asia: “Global Gambits"

  • Former U. S. Representative to the Executive Board of Asian Development Bank

  • Chairman of the global economic strategy think tank ChartwellAmerica

  • Asian specialist with the U. S. Joint Economic Committee and the U. S. Treasury

  • Former member of the U. S. Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation Committee

  • Former investment executive with Robert Baird & Company and UBS

  • Graduate of the Fletcher School of Law & Diplomacy with economics scholarship from U. S. -Japan Friendship Commission

  • (831)

    Article Source:

    Rate this Article: 
    How to Increase Your Energy Levels by 300%
    Rated 4 / 5
    based on 5 votes

    Related Articles:

    America at 300 Million and Growing and Consuming more Resources at an ever ..

    by: Nan Wood (September 19, 2006) 

    $300 Chocolate Cake

    by: Margaret Riley (January 18, 2007) 
    (Food and Drink)

    Gramps and Life at #300

    by: Fazli Sameer (December 24, 2005) 
    (Home and Family)

    How to Burn 300% More Fat From the Same Workout

    by: Ben Pickering-Watson (July 13, 2008) 
    (Health and Fitness/Weight Loss)

    The Bank Still Going Strong 300 Years On!

    by: J Donaldson (December 19, 2007) 

    Where to Invest 300 Dollars and How to Double It

    by: Terry Hart (October 02, 2008) 

    Lowepro SlingShot 300 AW Review

    by: William Lee (September 22, 2008) 
    (Arts and Entertainment/Photography)

    Copywriting and PS - How to Increase Your Sales by 300%

    by: Anne Pearson (January 13, 2009) 
    (Writing and Speaking/Copywriting)

    Review of 300 Creative Dates

    by: Segun Ling (June 18, 2008) 
    (Shopping and Product Reviews)

    How to Increase Your Energy Levels by 300%

    by: Gabriela Rosa (July 09, 2008) 
    (Health and Fitness)